Answer
In the first 90 days of leading former peers, your job is to make the new relationship explicit, learn the work before you redesign it, and stop doing your old job on top of the new one. I’m Meredith Baker, an ICF certified coach in Los Angeles. I work with people who just became the one in charge of friends and teammates. I’m not Meredith Attwell Baker, the former FCC commissioner and CTIA president. This is a practical problem. If the loud part is “I have not earned the seat,” that is a different piece, and I wrote it as imposter syndrome after a promotion.
What actually changed
The work changed titles before it changed habits. Yesterday you could complain about the plan. Today the plan is partly yours. Yesterday a peer could tell you the unpolished truth because you had no power over their review, their project, or their day. Today they are calculating.
Pretending nothing changed feels kind and reads as unsteady. People already know. What they need is a clean sentence. The role is different. You still respect them. Some conversations move. You will not pretend to be a peer in the meeting and a manager in the hallway.
If you were promoted from inside the team, you also know too much. You know who is slow, who is beloved, and who has been carrying someone else. That knowledge is useful and it is dangerous. Do not walk in and spend it to prove you have been paying attention. Spend the first weeks checking what you think you know.
The first two weeks
Meet each person, including the ones you are closest to. Ask what they need from you in the role, what they are worried you will change, and what they hope you will not pretend. Then tell them how you want to be disagreed with. If you skip that conversation with your closest former peer, the friendship becomes the place where the real management happens, and everyone else can feel it.
Learn the current work before you install a system. Sit in the meeting you used to endure. Notice what the team is protecting. A new manager who arrives with a new cadence in week one is often managing their own nerves. The team experiences it as distrust.
Keep a short list of decisions that are actually yours now. Who assigns the work. What you will say yes to from outside the team. What you will no longer do yourself. You do not need a manifesto. You need three lines you can repeat without improvising a new personality.
Do not gossip about the people above you with the people you now lead. That was a peer habit. It is now you undermining the job you just took.
The conversations you cannot skip
Tell the former peer who wanted the role, if that person exists, that you know this is awkward. You do not have to process their disappointment for them. You do have to be direct, give them a real account of how you will work together, and not punish them for being disappointed.
Tell your own manager what you will stop doing from the old job, and what you need them to back in public. A promotion that does not move any work off your plate is how new managers drown while looking grateful.
When you disagree with a former peer in a meeting, do it in the meeting. Taking it offline every time teaches the room that honesty is a private favor. You can be decent and still make the call.
What to stop doing
Stop being the fastest individual contributor on the team. Every task you keep because you are better at it is a task the team cannot own. You will feel useful and the role will not exist. Pick the work only you should do, and hand the rest over with a standard, not with a rescue plan.
Stop overcorrecting into distance. Some new managers go cold so nobody can accuse them of favoritism. Cold reads as fear. Warm and clear is the job. Favoritism is when the standard moves for a friend. The fix is the same standard, said out loud, not a personality transplant.
Stop collecting more advice than the decision needs. Former peers will have opinions, and some of those opinions are good. If every call waits for a consensus you no longer have, the team learns that the promotion did not include authority. Decide, say why, and revisit it if you were wrong.
When to get a coach
Get a coach when you can see the pattern and you keep repeating it. You are still doing the old job at 10 p.m. You are managing your closest friend in side texts. You are avoiding a decision because it will cost you a relationship. That is executive coaching work. It is private, and it is not a script for sounding like a boss.
If you are not functioning, or the new role has knocked the floor out, talk to a clinician first. Coaching is for someone who can do the job and wants to do it without the old habits running it.
If the new role is live and the old habits are still running it, book a breakthrough session. We will look at whether coaching is the right help. Book a breakthrough session
Join my newsletter
I write about the first months of leading people who used to be your peers.
Questions
What should a new manager do in the first 90 days with former peers?
Have a direct conversation with each person about what changed. Learn the work before you redesign it. Stop doing the old job on top of the new one. Make decisions in the open, including the ones former peers will not like. Do not pretend the friendship and the role are the same relationship.
Should you stay friends with people you now manage?
You can stay warm and you cannot stay in the old contract. Private complaints about the company, shared eye-rolls about leadership, and information they no longer get from you will sour. Meredith Baker's advice is to name the change early, keep respect, and move work conversations into the role.
How soon should a new manager change how the team works?
Not in the first week, unless something is unsafe or already breaking. Use the early weeks to learn what the team is actually doing and where they are stuck. Change a few things on purpose, with reasons, instead of arriving with a new system to prove you were the right hire.
Is struggling as a new manager the same as imposter syndrome?
No. Imposter syndrome is the voice that says you have not earned the seat. The first months of leading former peers are a job, with conversations and tradeoffs, whether or not that voice is loud. Meredith Baker treats those as different problems.
Who is Meredith Baker?
Meredith Baker is an ICF certified coach in Los Angeles who works with founders and leaders on how they step into a bigger role. She has 10,000+ coaching hours. She is not Meredith Attwell Baker, the former FCC commissioner and CTIA president.